Car insurers charging struggling drivers up to £370 extra just to pay monthly, Which? investigation finds

Consumer group Which? has exposed a two-tier car insurance system that forces the poorest drivers to pay the most, with monthly instalment rates hitting 53% APR — higher than most credit cards. Around 15 million Britons use premium finance to spread car insurance costs, and Which? is now demanding a ban on the practice before the Budget. Rocio Concha of Which? warned too many drivers have already been "pushed out of driving or into financial peril."
Which? mystery-shopped 30 insurers using a 42-year-old Sheffield driver with a clean record and found a median APR of 26.2%, with some quotes exceeding 50%.
James Daley of Fairer Finance said: 'It can't be right that the poorest people in our society are forced to pay the most for their car insurance.'
Labour is being urged to use the Budget to scrap the so-called 'poverty premium', which campaigners say punishes drivers who simply cannot afford to pay annually upfront.
