Experts fear Labour's plan to tear up 'pension freedoms' will lock 17 million savers into deals they don't want

Pensions minister Torsten Bell unveiled the 'Guided Retirement' consultation on Tuesday, proposing that workplace pension schemes must offer private sector workers a default income-for-life option as they approach retirement, automatically enrolling roughly 17 million savers unless they actively opt out. The plan effectively reverses the 'pension freedoms' reforms of the coalition era, which scrapped the obligation to buy an annuity and let savers spend or invest their pots as they chose. Experts warn that many people who would never voluntarily choose an annuity-style deal could find themselves locked in with little flexibility.
Steve Webb of LCP warns most people currently reject annuities and would struggle to change their mind once enrolled.
Jon Greer of Quilter says the default must be 'a safety net rather than a straitjacket' with real freedom to choose alternatives.
In 2025–26, around 46% of first-time pension pot accesses involved savers withdrawing the entire fund — the statistic Bell cited to justify the shake-up.
